Eli and Warner are business partners - and childhood best friends - whose lives get turned upside down when their pain-in-the-neck dads, David and Crawford move in with them.
Ghost Child Games is in need of a new video game concept. So Warner and Veronica encourage Eli to revert to his tried-and-true method of coming up with ideas: “medicinally enhanced” baked goods. But the guys discover an even better use for the treats when their pain-in-the-neck dads, David and Crawford start eating them and totally mellowing out.
Eli dates Veronica's friend Anne, an attractive but annoying comedian, with Eli having her move in to spite David. Meanwhile, a recording session for the company's new video game "Occue-Die Wall Street" gets out of hand when Crawford tries to help Warner with some "businessman" voice-over work.
Concerned about their dads' health, Warner and Eli takes them to get physicals, but Warner begins to worry about his mortality when the doctor dies before giving him his test results.
Since Eli has a history of being a Human Resources liability, Warner hires Janet, an older woman as a new assistant at the office, but the plan backfires when David and Crawford compete for her affections.
Eli and David are forced to sleep at the Ghost Child Games offices when bedbugs overtake the loft. Meanwhile, Camila gets the lead in a local theater production, and Crawford ends up being uncharacteristically helpful, much to the chagrin of Warner.
Eli and Warner mistakenly trigger an investigation of elder abuse, causing their dads to be placed in a foster care home. Eli and Warner's initial happiness soon turns into guilt, and they hatch a plan to rescue their fathers. Meanwhile, Crawford's childish, sloppy habits get between Camila and Warner.
When Eli and Warner fire one of their employees right before the holiday season, the ex-game designer seeks his revenge by including an offensive word in their family-friendly Christmas game. Meanwhile, Edna encourages David to get a job as a mall Santa in order to earn enough money to buy Eli a gift.
When Veronica gets sick, germaphobe Warner forces her go home. Sensing an opportunity, Eli takes care of her in hopes that his kindness will make her want to sleep with him.
When Camila goes out of town to visit her sister, she leaves Warner with his first family-free weekend in years – except for the fact that Crawford now lives with them. To solve the problem, Warner puts Crawford and David up in a hotel where the two are mistaken for a gay couple on their honeymoon.
When Crawford gets too drunk and accidentally ruins the Whittemores' couch, Camila insists that they all quit drinking so much. Then, Eli ignores David's constant complaining, and one of them ends up in the hospital for it.
When Crawford gets too drunk and accidentally ruins the Whittemores' couch, Camila insists that they all quit drinking so much. Then, Eli ignores David's constant complaining, and one of them ends up in the hospital for it.
