Nick Lachey returns to his hometown of Cincinnati to open a bar with his brother and 98 Degrees bandmate Drew; the brothers conduct important business research by going on a pub crawl.

The brothers visit a local brewery to figure out their bar's beer selection. After they each make a signature brew, they throw a keg party to determine whose creation will be served at Lachey's.

The brothers get opinions on possible menu items for the bar by holding a taste test during a Cincinnati Bengals tailgate; Nick's wife, Vanessa, pays a surprise visit to Ohio.